Stickett Inn Cafe | A Cozy Retreat for Coffee Lovers in Barryville, NY

Overview

Nestled along the scenic NY-97 corridor in Barryville, Stickett Inn Cafe offers more than just a meal—it's an experience rooted in warmth, community, and authentic flavors. This cozy, eclectic spot has earned its reputation as a favorite among locals and travelers alike, especially those seeking a blend of rustic charm and modern comfort.

The cafe’s menu centers around hearty, satisfying dishes like the Veggie Burrito and the Quesadilla De Pollo Chicken, both crafted with fresh ingredients that embrace the region’s wholesome, outdoor spirit. Pair these with their expertly brewed coffee or a creamy latte, and you have a meal that fuels both adventure and relaxation. Beyond coffee, the drink selection shines with creative twists on classics such as Manhattans and gimlets, plus a well-curated hard cider lineup that captures the essence of the local craft scene.

Stickett Inn Cafe’s intimate space invites conversation and connection. The friendly, knowledgeable baristas and staff create an atmosphere that feels like a welcoming retreat after a day exploring the nearby wilderness. Free WiFi and good vibes make it a prime stop for campers, hikers, and anyone looking to recharge. Regular visitors highlight the genuine hospitality—from Lia’s warm welcome to meaningful encounters with owners like John—making each visit memorable.

Whether you're drawn by the rich espresso, the vibrant flavors of their ceviche, or simply to soak in the cozy ambiance, Stickett Inn Cafe stands out as a community hub. It appeals to those who appreciate craft beverages, quality food, and an environment that reflects the rugged beauty of the Catskills. This is a destination as much for locals as for travelers craving a genuine taste of Barryville’s spirit.

Menu Highlights

See Full Menu

Amenities & Services

Popular for

Breakfast

Solo dining

Offerings

Alcohol

Cocktails

Coffee

Organic dishes

Small plates

Spirits

Vegetarian options

Wine

Atmosphere

Casual

Cosy

Trendy

What Customers Say

Anthony L

Dec 11,2025

5/5

I go camping each year in the area, and I make a duty to stop by this cafe. The baristas are the kindest, knowledgeable, great WiFi & great vibes. Best coffee in the area.

kate fernald

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Amazing hospitality, beautiful drinks! What a fun place to go. Recommend the Manhattan and the gimlet! Fun twists on classic drinks! Delicious hard cider too. Came home with some growlers So we could continue the vibe. Delicious ceviche! Can’t say enough. What a fun time! Can’t wait to rock the tshirts we bought bc my husband and I had such a fun evening! Thank you!

Chris Corcoran

Dec 11,2025

5/5

loved getting coffee at the Bang Bang Café@ Stickett’s! I’m was in Eldred for the weekend and I did my requisite search for coffee nearby and Google doesn’t mention this café, which seems to me to be a major oversight in the Google review universe. Small space, interior decor was cozy and eclectic, staff was super friendly, and the coffee was flat out delicious. My espresso pull was sweet and full of flavor, and the oat milk over ice made for a perfect drink for the end of a perfect day.

Michael Scodes

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Came to visit the area and the employee Lia was absolutely wonderful and made us feel so welcome! Then we got to meet John who is one of the owners and it was an absolute pleasure! The coffee, cider and food is amazing! Highly recommend to make this a pit stop. It’s so cozy and welcoming. Really gives that camping, wilderness, cozy vibe still!

Alina Morante

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Very friendly and comfy place, great drinks my husband ordered a cappuccino and it was so good! I ordered a Matcha and it was delicious!

Jen

Dec 11,2025

5/5

Wonderful coffee stop if driving near the town. There are loads of baked goods, drinks, and coffee options. The almond croissant was great. Barista was kind and made our order quickly.

Erick Holmes

Dec 11,2025

5/5

This is a SERIOUS five-star rating and review! Even though they were shut for the day, the staff still served us coffees. It was extremely kind (and I assume a very circumstantial) gesture. But the coffee was brewed perfectly and delicious. We bought a bag of coffee and he knew to grind is for a Mokka, which is a rare find, and we had a great chat before departing. When we come back to the area, we'll come back!