Menu of Stickett Inn Cafe in Barryville, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Located at 3380 NY-97 in Barryville, the Stickett Inn Cafe stands as a warm, inviting refuge for travelers and locals alike, melding rustic charm with exceptional culinary offerings. Known for its cozy ambiance that feels akin to a welcoming wilderness lodge, this cafe delivers not only on atmosphere but also on quality and flavor.

The menu is thoughtfully curated, with standout dishes that truly capture the spirit of the region’s hearty, yet fresh, fare. The Veggie Burrito is a vibrant option, packed with crisp, well-seasoned vegetables that offer both comfort and nutrition—perfect after a day spent outdoors. The Quesadilla De Pollo Chicken balances melty cheese with tender, flavorful chicken, delivering a satisfying, savory punch that pairs beautifully with the café’s drink selections.

Coffee enthusiasts will find a haven here. The latte is a must-try, praised for its smooth texture and expertly crafted balance of espresso and steamed milk. Many visitors, like Anthony L, regard Stickett Inn’s coffee as the best in the area, highlighting baristas’ friendly service and the café’s reliable WiFi, making it an ideal spot to relax or work.

Stickett Inn also excels beyond coffee, showcasing a diverse drink menu that includes inventive twists on classics such as the Manhattan and gimlet, alongside delightful hard ciders. This range reflects a thoughtful commitment to craft beverages, satisfying a spectrum of tastes whether you seek a robust espresso-based drink or a refreshing cocktail.

The staff’s hospitality enhances the experience, with genuine kindness and knowledge that make every visit memorable. Guests like Michael Scodes and Alina Morante have noted the warm welcomes and personal touches that elevate their time here. The intimate, eclectic interior complements this warmth, creating a setting that’s both comfortable and visually engaging.

Overall, Stickett Inn Cafe stands out not only for its menu highlights—Veggie Burrito, Quesadilla De Pollo Chicken, and standout lattes—but also for its holistic dining experience. It feels like a carefully curated corner of the wilderness, blending robust flavors with genuine hospitality, making it a must-visit stop in Barryville for food lovers and coffee aficionados alike.